Sorry, but marriage and sex DON'T go together
By SADIE NICHOLAS
Carrie Jones hasn't had sex with her husband Hal, a City banker,
for the past four years. Nor does she want to. Sex is something she can
no longer summon the effort to endure - with the man she married, at
least.
She admits she stays in her sexless relationship for the sake of
her children, aged nine and 11, and will remain celibate until the day
they are grown up and she feels able to leave. At which point, she
confesses, she will probably abandon her husband and begin a sexual
odyssey to find the satisfaction that eludes her.
An unusual case? A sorry lack of libido? She insists not. "If I
thought I was unique in my sexual disappointment I'd probably be
suicidal," muses Carrie, 45, a publishing executive, who lives in North
London with Hal and their children.
"I remember the first time my girlfriends and I admitted that
we all felt the same about married sex as parents: we couldn't be
bothered with it and felt guilty for not wanting to sleep with our
husbands. It was a revelation. I remember thinking: 'Thank God! It's
not just me!'
"Now I believe there are thousands of other married women who would
love to admit sex isn't all it's cracked up to be. But, if the constant
cliches in women's magazines and chick-lit are to believed, we should
all be enjoying prowess in the boardroom and swooning every night in
the bedroom.
"It's the great taboo that no one dares admit - that sex is often a let-down."
So convinced is Carrie that her experience of sex in marriage -
initially pleasant, dwindling to nothing at all after having children -
is a universal one that she has just written a book, under an assumed
name, highlighting the disappointment of her sex life.
"It's a sort of 'Frigid Jones' Diary'," she laughs, though she
is not joking. "I want to break the taboo. Sex frequently isn't the
chandelier-swinging experience that certain authors would have us
believe is every woman's rite of passage.
"For me, the sense of being special to Hal faded away just as
it did with previous boyfriends. I became obsessed with agony columns,
poring over letters talking of boring marriages and the temptation of
affairs and willing just one agony aunt to advise someone to run off
with a lover.
"Of course, they never did. It was always: 'Go and work at your
marriage.' But I didn't want to work on mine. I wanted someone to say:
'Actually, perhaps nothing will make you want to sleep with your
husband again,' which is how I feel.
"I've made my choice. For now I'm caught up in marriage's net,
bound up with responsibilities to my children. My interest in sex with
the person I was supposed to be closest to has died. I could leave but
for now I'll wait because of the desolation it would wreak on my
family.
"I want to maintain the family unit because it makes other
things possible, like doing things together with the children. But one
day, when they are older and I can think about my own needs again, I
may leave and start all over again.
"In the meantime, I want to tell other women that they are not
alone in not wanting to have sex with their long-term partners. I don't
think it's possible to maintain the passion of the initial chase. But
it doesn't mean you won't experience those feelings again with someone
else."
She may be considering an extreme - some would say distasteful
and selfish - course of action for the future but Carrie's upbringing
was very conventional. A Cambridge graduate, she was raised in
Yorkshire, the only child of teacher parents whose marriage, she says,
"was pretty dull".
She and Hal were introduced by friends when they were both 33, and she admits that they "clicked brilliantly".
They had sex up to five times a week before having children. But
like her previous experiences, the longer the relationship lasted, the
more disappointing it became.
"The problem is that sex in a long-term relationship inevitably
becomes less alluring as domesticity sets in," she says. "Hal and I
were very well suited in terms of our personalities and common interest
in books, music, art and films but we never had the kind of wild,
passionate sex that leaves you wanting more.
"Like most successful long-term partnerships, our relationship wasn't built on sex or passion. At best, sex was simply fine."
But even the "fine" sex Carrie recalls was soon replaced by despondency once the couple's first child was born.
"I did the middle-class mother thing in a big way," she says. "I
gave up my career, breast-fed each child for a year and spent my days
in a dizzy whirl of playgroups and coffee mornings.
"I'd flipped from wife to mother, and it gave me excuses -
often genuine - to cold-shoulder my husband's sexual advances. He knew
I was tired from the children and was always very understanding. He's
an unusually kind and tolerant man." Indeed he must be.
Certainly, once the first flush of love and lust gives way to
familiarity, domesticity and parenthood, few would argue that making
love is the wanton adventure it was. But Carrie goes one step further.
She believes that marriage and motherhood are simply not conducive to
having a sex life at all.
"Providing a stable home for children is totally incompatible
with having an exciting sex life. The two things are violently at
odds," she adds.
"After umpteen years with the same person, sex is bound to get
boring. Some people put themselves first, have affairs or simply leave
their marriages in search of sexual adventure.
"I've chosen to sacrifice sexual thrills in order to do the right thing by my kids."
But a martyr Carrie isn't, and surely Hal does not feel she is
doing the right thing by him. The couple still share a bed, though
physical contact is strictly off limits.
"We've never discussed the demise of our sex life," she says. "It was more a case of reaching a low ebb of energy on my part.
"For a long time I didn't even realise it was the end of marital
sex for us. But when years have passed, you realise it ended a long
time ago."
Unbelievably, her poor, unsuspecting husband is not only
unaware of her plans to leave him. He also, she insists, has no idea
that she has written a book or posed for these pictures. She seems as
confident of him not finding out as she is that he is understanding of
her feelings.
For when asked whether she worries that Hal may seek sexual
gratification elsewhere, she says: "I'm not concerned. I don't think
that would happen. It's not Hal's fault that I wish to remain celibate;
it's nothing he's said or done. He's a good man and a great dad. It's
just that I don't want to be intimate with him any more."
Such cold words must leave her husband reeling? She insists not.
"There's a general understanding between us that I'm keeping the
family unit together," she says. "Children need to be brought up by
parents in a monogamous marriage. I wouldn't want to blow that apart,
and I certainly wouldn't want the burden of being a single parent.
"I know from taking the kids on holiday on my own once when Hal
was working that having sole responsibility for them is exhausting."
So what of her sexual history? It seems that Carrie wasn't
always this uninterested in sex. She admits to having 23 lovers before
she married.
"Ten were proper boyfriends," she recalls. "I regretted having
sex with six of them, loved three of them but only one of the 23 ever
gave me an orgasm.
"As I entered my thirties, it was obvious my sex life had a
recurring, rather depressing pattern: intense desire to begin with
followed, if the relationship survived long enough, by a slow winding
down into indifference.
"Only an affair with a married man called John bucked the trend. But that was doomed by its very nature."
Five years ago, Carrie almost cheated on her husband after regaining contact with an old flame on the website Friends Reunited.
"I nearly lost my virginity to Mark when we were 17, but my
mother arrived home as we enjoyed a fumble in my bedroom," she recalls.
"He was gorgeous, looked like a man even back then in his school uniform, and remained in my consciousness for all those years.
"When I looked on Friends Reunited, it was an enormous thrill
just to find Mark's name. I e-mailed him immediately. He replied with
an update on his life and said he was single - I was intoxicated.
"We began to exchange flirtatious emails, then text messages
and phone calls which became increasingly fraught with sexual tension.
"After a few months of tantalising cyber sex, I booked a flight
to go and see him in Germany, where he was living, over Easter 2003.
But between booking the flight and the departure date, Mark found a
girlfriend. I was distraught, my hopes of sexual adventure dashed."
Did Carrie not feel an ounce of guilt about her plans to cheat on Hal? "I had been feeling so sour about my sex life with Hal.
"But, back in contact with Mark, I suddenly discovered that my sexual urge wasn't dead as I had feared, just dormant.
"It was glorious to feel aroused again, and those feelings blocked out any guilt I might otherwise have felt about Hal.
"For the few months that Mark and I flirted online, I had two
existences: one where I cooked and cleaned and went frigidly to bed at
night. And another where I had butterflies in my stomach and stole off
to write sexy, flirty emails and text messages to a man I hadn't seen
for more than 20 years."
Eventually Carrie was forced to confess her feelings about Mark
to her husband after he discovered the email exchanges between the two
on her computer. Astonishingly, Hal comforted her while she sobbed and,
she says, for a short time the pair were closer and more able to talk.
"But as time went on, it became clear this was just an
interlude in our marriage rather than a permanent change," admits
Carrie. "The old coldness returned and, since then, I have been unable
to have sex with my husband."
Such a sorry tale of a sexless, unfulfilling marriage is in
stark contrast to the current throng of writers littering the Amazon
book charts with jaw-dropping memoirs of lurid sex lives.
Carrie admits that part of her envies those authors who claim
to be having lots of sex and, more significantly, love it. The other
part of her just doesn't believe them.
"I do wonder if they are just writing what they think the
audience wants to hear," she says. "I read their accounts of wild sex
lives and then ponder my own sexual encounters and wonder: 'Where was
the fun, the screaming ecstasy, the fireworks?'"
Perhaps when her children are grown up, Carrie will do as she intends and leave her marriage.
Only then will she know whether the fantasy of taking in
multiple lovers and never committing to one man is a greater thrill
than being in a monogamous marriage.
You can find this article here.
Chatboard (0)